The menu at Picholine showcases "the ferocious commitment to quality and the restless inventiveness of its chef-owner, Terrance Brennan," stated The New York Times. Featuring the highest quality seasonal ingredients, his French-Mediterranean dishes are original interpretations of classic flavors from France, Spain and Italy. Delectable "preludes" include Sea Urchin Panna Cotta with Chilled Ocean Consommé and Caviar, and Crisp Sweetbreads with Pickled Crudité and Raisin-Mustard Emulsion; signature entrées include Diver Sea Scallops with Cauliflower Silk and Blood Orange Grenobloise, and Heirloom Chicken "Kiev" with Chanterelles and Liquid Foie Gras. Desserts like Passion Fruit "Cannoli" with Coconut Tapioca and Exotic Fruit Soup, and Pear "Torchon with Smoked Maple Ice Cream and Spice Bread Crumbs sweetly round out the restaurant's offerings. Picholine's renowned cheese cart displays more than 60 of the world's finest artisanal cheeses.
Brennan's 2006 redesign of Picholine transformed the restaurant with a sleek design that mirrors the modern sensibilities of his Mediterranean cuisine. The no-reservations wine and cheese bar features purple leather banquettes and walls upholstered in a grey-lavender stripe. Soaring 10-foot boysenberry velvet curtains separate the wine and cheese bar from the elegant dining rooms, where grey mohair banquettes and custom-made grey leather chairs with deep purple piping are reflected in custom mirrors.
In addition to 84 seats in the main dining rooms, L'Olivier, the restaurant's spacious private dining room, can accommodate an additional 22 guests. Picholine's intimate Wine Room seats up to 8 guests. Tucked in a corner of the 2,500 bottle-lined Wine Room is the famous Cheese Cave.
The restaurant received a James Beard Foundation nomination for the country's Outstanding Restaurant in 2007, and was awarded two stars in the 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011 editions of Michelin Guide New York City.